Honouring the “Wordsmith / Godstriver / Hospitaller”

Jim Cotter Jim Cotter's journey with leukemia has taken him heavenwards now (I was sad to read of his death in the Church Times obituaries this week). But what a great legacy he has left us, of wonderfully crafted liturgies and some of the deepest and most honest spiritual writing of our times – as he put it,

'I think I have been exploring, as a pilgrim soul, what it might mean to unfold afresh my spiritual and religious inheritance, and it has been both a personal and a public concern to try and connect that tradition with the experiences of being gay, undergoing two years of serious depression, and, more recently, living with leukaemia. In their time each of these has been a stigma, information that few people would wish to reveal when applying for a job.'

I was surprised and overjoyed to encounter Jim at Aberdaron in 2008, whose vicar he had been for just two weeks, and to share morning prayer with him, the two of us in that windblown church on the edge of the Lleyn Peninsular, haunted by the near presence of a previous poet-incumbent R. S. Thomas. Jim's latter days were spent facing the challenge of engaging Aberdaron church's 10,000 annual visitors with the spirituality of the place, and 'providing nudges' to tourists and pilgrims alike (see my interview with him in the Church Times Travel Supplement, January 2011 [pdf]). He'd been exploring that gentle sort of hospitality for some time before, at Llandecwyn, and I'll always be grateful to him for his pioneering the Small Pilgrim Places network, which continues and – who knows – maybe one of our small churches might become one? It'd be a fitting tribute to a man who variously described himself as a 'Wordsmith', 'Godstriver' Hospitaller, and for whom I give thanks today.

The Morning People

Acts 10.34-43, Matthew 28.1-10

Queen Camel, Weston Bampfylde, Easter Day, 20 April 2014

Are you a morning person?

Mary Magdelene and the other Mary must have been morning people, for they rose before dawn on the first day of the week to go and see the tomb where they had laid Jesus to rest two days before.

They were morning people – but what sort of morning people? Either the sort who get up early simply because they can’t sleep – for anxiety, sickness of the heart or mind? Or the sort who can’t stay in bed because they are so keen to grasp the potential of a bright new day – lovers of life, longing to get out and embrace it?

They could have been either sorts of morning people, these two Marys – restless throughout the Sabbath, recalling the terrible events of the day before, sleepless for fear of what may have happened to Jesus’ body. Or, their hearts believing what they had heard Jesus tell them – that he would rise on the third day – not wanting to waste a moment to go and discover whether this joyful event had occurred.

It’s quite possible that they might have been all these things combined – for as you and I know, our inner life seldom runs smoothly, and especially at times of crisis we fluctuate between hopelessness and hopefulness, anxiety and assuredness, joyfulness and fear. No doubt that Mary Magdalene, the other Mary and all the disciples who shared in the revelation of the risen Jesus, would continue to feel a combination of these things that day. Indeed Matthew tells us that after the angel had given them the resurrection message, ‘They left the tomb quickly with fear and great joy’.

There’s a deeper sense in which we can say that these two women were morning people. 

They were morning people because they had embraced the good news of God’s kingdom in their lives; they had seen its power at work personally and in the new community of believers to which they belonged; and that morning they had seen its power at work more clearly than ever – resurrection power, the power to overcome death.

Mary Magdalene first embraced the good news of God’s kingdom and seen his resurrection power at work, when Jesus cleansed her of “seven demons” [1]. It was some form of mental or physical illness she was suffering – an illness which would have caused her to be excluded from the rest of society, ostracised because in her madness or sickness they would have dubbed her ‘unclean’. When Jesus healed her he revealed the nature of the kingdom of God – that it was a way of life in which the excluded ones were now included. When Jesus healed her she felt the power of the resurrection change her life – she was whole in body and mind – and in status too, fully restored to society – and in that moment her life began again.

And the woman who Matthew calls ‘the other Mary’ – who was she? Not Jesus’ mother, or Matthew would surely have said. Perhaps Mary, the sister of Martha and Lazarus, who had once anointed the Lord with perfume and wiped his feet with her hair and to whom Jesus revealed his resurrection power when he raised Lazarus from the dead. [2].

It is perhaps more likely that ‘the other Mary’ is the one Matthew earlier mentions being with Mary Magdalene at the foot of the cross when Jesus died, and at the tomb when they placed his body there – ‘Mary the mother of James and Joseph’. [3] We know nothing else about this Mary – except that she was clearly part of the first group of those who had embraced Jesus’ teachings about the kingdom of God, grasped its significance and felt its power in their lives. A morning person, for it had dawned on her that in Christ she was a new person – not constrained by the laws which radically diminished the role of women in that society, but raised to the same level as all the other believers. This Mary, like all the other women in Jesus’ company, and all the other outsiders and ordinary folk he embraced, experienced the new reality of God’s kingdom which Paul later expressed to the Galatians: that in Christ ‘There is neither Jew nor Gentile, neither slave nor free, nor is there male and female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.’ [4]

Morning people are those who have been resurrected to a whole new way of seeing the world. No longer contained by tribal identities, no longer limited by their gender or class or constrained by their political or religious identity, but many different people, all one in Christ.

Morning people are those who have been resurrected to a whole new way of being in the world. Now able to embrace as brother and sister those who they would previously have avoided, or demonised, or fought. In a community where all the old tribal barriers have disappeared, all the old anxieties raised by our grasping at the things we feel necessary to keep our place in the tribe have disappeared, to be replaced by a generosity of spirit which is based on nothing in this world except the way of Christ’s kingdom breaking in by the power of the resurrection. 

We can be like the two Marys, morning people full of fear and great joy at the new life which Jesus invites us now to live. A challenging life in its rejection of all the dreams we hold for our status and our comfort, and its invitation to embrace the way of God’s kingdom which Jesus taught in his parables and sermons. A radical life in its rejection of our identity as members of a particular class, or club, or nation, or faith, and its invitation to see Christ in all people, to find Christ in community with people radically not like us.

We can be like the two Marys: or we can be like the guards – morning people who only feel fear, for Matthew tells us that when they saw the angel at the empty tomb, ‘For fear of him [they] shook and became like dead men’. 

No wonder they shook – for the angel’s appearance was unlike anything these guards would have ever seen, something outside their ordered world of rote and rule, of fixed identities and lines of command. And even worse – they shook for the sight of the empty tomb, the tomb they had been ordered to guard closely for their commanding officers’ concern that any loss of that particular body would cause great trouble for them in the restless ferment of Jerusalem at Passover time.

Fearing for their punishment, the guards were way too scared of the angel and his announcement to perceive the power of the kingdom of God to release them from their captivity to their ordered, limited world into a new social order eclipsing all they had ever seen or known. It’s a fear which many of us share when woken to the claims of the kingdom of God and the power of the resurrection, for it is hard to leave behind the security of our old ways of being and allow ourselves ‘to be transformed by the renewing of our minds’ (as Paul puts it [5]) and to embrace Christianity not as a tribal thing, not as a class thing, not as a means to get us to heaven, but rather something which will do that but first will liberate our relationships with others on earth so that we experience heaven here and now and forever, and death becomes just a stage on our joyous journey. 

The good news of Easter is that, like Mary Magdalene and the other Mary, we can be morning people – full of fear and great joy at the news of the resurrection, embracing the way of God’s kingdom.

The world needs these sort of morning people today: the sort of people who when they step out of bed each day, have one foot in the kingdom of this earth, in the society in which they live and work, and one foot in the kingdom of God whose resurrection power they have embraced and whose ways they seek to follow. For them, eternal life has already come, it’s for their future but it is also for here and now, in the way they live their lives to and for others.

They are the ones equipped to shake the world out of its destructive patterns of tribalism and misplaced desire, to help humanity to find new ways of being together. These are the Desmond Tutu’s and the Pope Francis’s of the world – and they don’t just live in bishop’s palaces, people like them live in villages like these, they sit in pews like these, you’re among them today.

Do not be afraid. I know that you are looking for Jesus, who was crucified. He is risen. Go ahead and look for him. You will find him. This is the good news of Easter: we can be morning people. Halleluia!

 

Notes

[1] See Luke 8:2 and Mark 16:9  

[2] John 11.1-45

[3] Matthew 27.55-61 

[4] Galatians 3:28-29

[5] Romans 12:2

 

Crucified by people just like us: Good Friday prayers

 

Crucified Lord, on this sober day, at the foot of your cross

We reflect that you were crucified by people just like us:

Religious people, political people, social people.

And we make our prayers for those being crucified with you in our world today. …

 

The opening lines to my prayers on West Camel village green this Good Friday morning.

Crucified by people just like us: Good Friday prayers

Ecumenical Open Air Service, West Camel Green, 18 April 2014

 

Crucified Lord, on this sober day, at the foot of your cross 

We reflect that you were crucified by people just like us:

Religious people, political people, social people.

And we make our prayers for those being crucified with you in our world today.

 

Jesus, you were crucified by people just like us:

Religious people, who, you once said ‘on the outside look righteous to others, but inside … are full of hypocrisy and lawlessness’

We are saddened and repentant of all the wrongs which are being done today in the name of religion, and pray for those who are wronged:

  • Christians in Sudan, Pakistan and other parts of the world being persecuted and killed for their faith;
  • Muslims in the UK being ostracised, unjustly demonised and excluded from our society;
  • All those who are keen on God, inspired by Jesus but find the church too difficult a community to belong to any more.

For those being crucified with you by religion:

Lord, in your mercy,

Hear our prayer.

 

Jesus, you were crucified by people just like us:

Political people, concerned with keeping power and position at any costs, who will ‘kill the prophets and stone those sent to you’, as you once said, 

We are saddened and repentant of all the political violence in our world today, and pray for those who are wronged:

  • All victims of war and terror, in Syria, Ukraine and other troubled parts of the world;
  • All those suffering poverty in poor nations exploited by wealthy corporations, and all those suffering poverty in wealthy nations like ours, and being blamed for their situation rather than aided;
  • All those driven from their homeland to escape persecution and the effects of famine or war, finding it hard to find a welcome anywhere else.

For those being crucified with you by politics and power:

Lord, in your mercy,

Hear our prayer.

 

Jesus, you were crucified by people just like us:

Socialised people, ‘sheep without a shepherd’, you called them, 

Crowds chasing dreams, tossed and blown from one trend to another, from Jesus to Barabbas:

We are saddened and repentant of our pursuit of those things which will never satisfy us, and pray for those whose lives are especially damaged in this way:

  • Those addicted to drugs or wealth or sex or winning;
  • Those driven towards suicide through a sense of failure and lostness;
  • Those disappointed by you because you won’t end suffering, and cannot see that you suffer with them;

For those being crucified with you by the potent power of the crowd and its desires:

Lord, in your mercy,

Hear our prayer.

 

A moment of silence for our own thoughts and prayers at the foot of the Cross.

 

Lord Jesus Christ,

look with mercy on we, your family

in our constant betrayals of you

      and of those who we give up to suffer with you as you suffered upon the cross;

for you are alive and glorified with the Father and the Holy Spirit,

one God, now and for ever. Amen.

 

The Lord’s Prayer is said

 

Standing at the foot of the cross,

as our Saviour taught us, so we pray

 

Our Father, who art in heaven, ….

Jesus – a funny sort of king

…

His kingdom, he would tell the people,

Is free of all fighting and crime.

It is one you can’t see, but can grow in your heart

And is everywhere all of the time.

 

He didn’t come into the city

In a carriage horse-drawn and gold

He came on a donkey he’d borrowed

And people waved palms in the road.

 

But the people soon turned on this young king;

He wasn’t the fighter they sought

One to smash all their foes and bloody the nose 

Of the emperor and all of his court.

 

This king became the victim

Of the worst crime in all history:

The innocent king who loved everyone

Was killed on a cross-shaped tree.

 

But this king was someone so special

That his story didn’t end that dark day.

He came back alive and forgave all those

Who had murdered and put him away.

 

A king full of love and forgiveness:

It’s wierd how the world could reject him.

He went up to heaven but his spirit’s on earth 

In the hearts of all who accept him.

 

His kingdom has no anthem 

But still the people sing: hallelujah, 

Hello, hail, to Jesus, 

A funny sort of king.

 …

 

Extracted from my talk / poem Jesus – a funny sort of king for Palm Sunday after a procession with donkeys at Weston Bampfylde.

 

Jesus – a funny sort of king

Cam Vale Benefice Palm Sunday Service, 13 April 2014

(after a procession with donkeys)

 

They shouted, “Hosanna to the Son of David!” – meaning “King of the Jews”

Jesus was “King of the Jews” – but a funny sort of king….

What sort of place would you expect a king to be born in? (… Jesus born in a stable… )

What sort of friends would you expect a king to have? (… Jesus friends were ordinary people… ) 

When a king comes into town, what sort of vehicle would you expect them to travel in (or on)? (… Jesus came on a donkey… )

Why did Jesus come into town on a donkey? What was he trying to say? (… That he was not like any other king, his kingdom was different… )

Jesus came into Jerusalem by the back gate. Pilate came in by the other gate, the main gate. 

Jesus’ procession mimicked, critiqued Pilate’s…. and – in the world of kings like Pilate and Herod – staked a claim for the Kingdom of God.

Jesus was making a very clear statement: the Kingdom of God is opposed to the kingdoms of this world.

Not a kingdom of power, wealth, military might, but a Kingdom of love, joy and peace

This is the claim which got him crucified;

This is the reality in which everyone who believes in him now lives…. 

And so the Psalm Sunday message for us today is:

The Kingdom of God is here! Hosanna!

 

Jesus – a funny sort of king

  

He was born nowhere near a palace

With nurses and soft white sheets;

He was born in a barn in the cold of the night

While people passed by in the streets.

 

His parents were not at all noble,

His mother was really a girl;

His father, a carpenter, made things in wood:

Theirs was an ordinary world.

 

Of what he did in his schooldays

All we know is this one fact:

He spent lots of time in the temple,

A strange way for a young boy to act. 

 

You’d expect a young ruler to go training

With the army to learn how to lead;

But this young king went around healing

And comforting all those in need. 

 

He was an unnoticed guest at a wedding

In Cana most of the time

But at the end of the night they all knew him:

He’d turned lots of water to wine.

 

The friends of this young king were normal,

Not famous or gifted or rich.

Some spent their days catching fishes,

And others just lived in a ditch.

 

His kingdom, he would tell the people,

Is free of all fighting and crime.

It is one you can’t see, but can grow in your heart

And is everywhere all of the time.

 

He didn’t come into the city

In a carriage horse-drawn and gold

He came on a donkey he’d borrowed

And people waved palms in the road.

 

But the people soon turned on this young king;

He wasn’t the fighter they sought

One to smash all their foes and bloody the nose 

Of the emperor and all of his court.

 

This king became the victim

Of the worst crime in all history:

The innocent king who loved everyone

Was killed on a cross-shaped tree.

 

But this king was someone so special

That his story didn’t end that dark day.

He came back alive and forgave all those

Who had murdered and put him away.

 

A king full of love and forgiveness:

It’s wierd how the world could reject him.

He went up to heaven but his spirit’s on earth 

In the hearts of all who accept him.

 

His kingdom has no anthem 

But still the people sing: hallelujah, 

Hello, hail, to Jesus, 

A funny sort of king.

 

(Poem oringinally written for the children of Lydford and Boasley Cross Schools, West Devon, in 2011 and posted here)

 

 

 

Man up #1 – If only you had been here, my brother would not have died

Back in the pulpit today! The first of an Easter series of talks which I've entitled Man up… contemplating Jesus' moral confusion between continuing his ministry at a crucial juncture, or visiting his sick friend Lazarus, and what he did when he realised he'd got it wrong… Man up #1 – If only you had been here, my brother would not have died.

Man up #1 – If only you had been here, my brother would not have died

Ezekiel 37.1-14, John 11.1-45

Sparkford, Weston Bampfylde, Lent 5, 6 April 2014

  

‘If only you had been here, my brother would not have died.’

 In John’s gospel, the story of Jesus raising Lazarus from the dead prefigures Jesus’ own resurrection, it reveals his identity as The Resurrection and the Life. And this gives us believers great confidence that in Christ we will ourselves overcome death. It is a tremendous theological statement about the power of the divine Jesus. But if you strip away John’s running commentary on the story you get to another great truth about Jesus. The basic events of those two days stand alone to reveal Jesus the man, and how he dealt with a situation which each of us faces quite often – what we should do when presented with two equally positive and pressing choices. And what we can do later when it looks like the choice we made was the wrong one.

‘If only you had been here, my brother would not have died.’ 

 The gospel story shows us a Jesus conflicted – between continuing in his ministry at a time when his mission to preach the good news of God’s kingdom was gaining momentum, and interrupting his ministry to go to his friend Lazarus who he has been told was ill. 

The story tells us that when Jesus heard the news about Lazarus’ illness he stayed where he was for two days. Now, to me, that sounds like the actions of someone like me or you, who are inclined to put things off, say we’ll get round to them tomorrow, tell ourselves it can wait, and then regret it when two days later we discover that we can’t make that visit any more because the person we thought was just a bit ill turns out to have passed away. I like that it makes Jesus sound like me or you, because I firmly believe that he was just like me or you, that’s how we can relate to him, that’s how he can relate to us.

 On the other hand Jesus staying where he was for two days might have been a decision he took after spending time in prayer – asking the Father what he should do now. And it was the Father who told him to stay where he was awhile. To me, this makes Jesus sound like Ezekiel, a man desiring to go where God wanted him to go, and learned to wait on God for his next step. 

The hand of the Lord was upon me, [Ezekiel said]

and he brought me out by the Spirit of the Lord

and set me down in the middle of the valley;

and it was full of bones.

Here is the testimony of a man who in one sense doesn’t know what he is doing. He knows that he is following God – very closely. He feels that it is the Spirit of God who is leading him – very consciously. He senses that he is where he is because that is where God wants him to be at that particular time – very clearly. Because Ezekiel has opened his heart to the promptings of God’s Spirit we might assume that he is prepared for anything. But he doesn’t know what will come next in that very strange place of dry bones.

And I suggest that in John’s story we see Jesus doing what Ezekiel did all those years before him: walking in the Spirit, following God by instinct; trusting his Father by faith; opening his heart to the promptings of God’s Spirit.  And me or you, when we’re walking with God quite closely, that’s what we do too. We don’t know what’s around the corner. But we know where God wants us now, and for now, that is enough.

John suggests that Jesus knew Lazarus was dying – and wanted him to die, so he could perform a miracle to persuade his disciples that he was divine. I suggest that that portrays Jesus as something he was not – a superhuman who knew precisely what was coming, and who could make cold, calculating, heartless decisions about what to do next.

I suggest that Jesus didn’t know Lazarus was dying – not just then, anyway, not at first, not till two days later when things had become much clearer to him. I would rather underline this very strong concern I have – to be clear how fully human Jesus was.

No-one in scripture makes it clearer to Jesus how fully human he was than those two sisters, his close friends Martha and Mary, as one after the other, in tones of voice we can only imagine, they each say, ‘If only you had been here, my brother would not have died.’

It was when Jesus was on the way to the village, with Martha, and Mary ran out from the house to meet him, followed by the others who were in the house, and Mary fell at his feet, and said, “Lord, if you had been here, Lazarus would not have died!”, and she wept, and all the people who were with her started weeping too. 

Why didn’t you Man Up, the sisters seemed to be saying, why didn’t you put your ambitions for mission to one side for a while and do the right thing for Lazarus and us, your closest friends? 

It was at that moment that Jesus broke down and shed the tears of a man who realised he had lost his dearest friend. And the tears of a man who realised that a choice he made two days ago may have been the wrong one.

Jesus’ response to the sisters’ cries is summed up in two simple, deeply moving words, the shortest verse in the bible: Jesus wept. Jesus wept: the most human reaction a God could ever make to a human catastrophe.

I value that small scene so much because there, again, Jesus did what we would do in a similar position. If you are superhuman and you know precisely what is coming and you can calculate everything in this situation so clearly that you have no doubt about it, then you do not weep. If you are absolutely clear that each choice you make is undoubtedly the right one, and never have any regrets, then you do not weep. If you are like that then you’re not human at all. You haven’t got a heart.

Jesus wept; which showed he had a heart. I’m so grateful to him that he did, because, again, that makes Jesus sound like me or you, and I firmly believe that he was just like me or you, that’s how we can relate to him, that’s how he can relate to us.

So, am I saying that Jesus was not divine? Not at all – there’s no doubt he performed this great miracle and there’s no doubt that persuades us he was divine. But I think that the most wonderful thing about Jesus is that he was fully divine and fully human. Indeed, to make it more wonderful still – Jesus, now, is fully human and fully divine. He can’t be less than either of them. And he can’t be more. The tears of a man who had lost his friend, were the tears of a God who would conquer death. The tears of a man who regretted a difficult choice he made, were the tears of a God who now has history in the palm of his hand.

The next thing that Jesus did – between weeping and raising Lazarus from the dead – was to pray to his father. It’s the sort of thing which you or I would do when in a conflicted situation: realise that we need the advice, the wisdom of a beloved and trusted elder. It’s the first stage of him Manning Up. It’s the sort of thing which we believers do daily, turn to God for guidance through the twists and turns of each hour. Jesus’ devotion to God in this moment shows up his humanness again; that he prayed to God as his Father, underlines his divinity.

I understand where John was coming from when he highlighted Jesus’ divinity. He was writing in the first century when there were still a lot of doubts about who Jesus really was; and it was a lot easier for his detractors to see him as a wayward preacher, a quack miracle-worker, than as the Son of God. John had to tell his story to underline what the believers knew to be true – Jesus was the Son of God. 

Today the world sees God, Jesus, faith differently. And maybe today people find it easy to dismiss Jesus if our only argument is to prove he is God, because they’re not that sure about God anyway. But they may be more interested in a Jesus who we talk about as the God who is fully human, who knows what it means to live by faith day-to-day, who maybe gets his timing wrong occasionally, who cries at the terrible loss of a friend. Who regrets a choice that he made. And who conquers death.

Man Up, said Martha and Mary to Jesus. And once he had finished weeping, he did. 

  

Notes

[1] A reworking of the sermon John 11 – Lazarus & Jesus – and an argument with John, preached at  Christ Church Norris Green, 13/3/2005