Zechariah 4.1–6a, 10b–14, Matthew 16.13–19
The Festival of Peter and Paul, 29 June 2025,
Eldroth (Benefice service)
It can be rare to see men embrace; and when we do, it may be under exceptional circumstances.
Two heavyweight boxers in the ring share a respectful hug at the end of their close-fought fight, before the winner on points is announced.
A best man holds an emotional groom in his arms, in acknowledgement that their bachelor days are over, in anticipation of the unknown new life beginning for them that day.
A father and son embrace awkwardly outside the young man’s university hall of residence, in an unspoken attempt to express their love and care, before the father leaves the son behind.
Then there’s Yorkshiremen… I was moved this week watching Amanda Owen’s sons Reuben and Miles talking about the terrifying day when Miles had a severe diabetic attack which would have been fatal had the Air Ambulance not lifted him to hospital. Reuben’s few words on this topic were considered and profound: “I’m glad you di’nt keel owver”, he said, and Miles gave his brother a brief, uncomplicated, meaningful hug around the shoulders before they rode off on their trail bikes into the mud. [1]
The icon of Saint Peter and Saint Paul embracing is a curious thing. The 15th century Greek iconographer Angelos Ako-tan-tos is credited with creating the first icon of this kind, and many artists have followed since, including Tamara Rig-ish-vili of Tbilisi, Georgia. Her icon, featured on the front of this week’s newsletter, follows the conventional style. [2]
If you look at it you’ll see Peter on the left and Paul to the right. One of the first things you might notice is that their faces touch but their eyes don’t meet. They are staring past each other. It doesn’t look like a fond embrace. This coolness suggests that although these men were co-leaders of the early missionary church, they were quite different in background and temperament; it admits that in their opinions on faith, the gospel and the Church, they seldom saw eye to eye. [3]
In background, Peter – born Simon – was a Galilean fisherman, whilst Paul – born Saul – was a Roman citizen from Tarsus, in the then Roman Province of Syria. Simon would have learned his scriptures in his home synagogue at Bethsaida, whilst Saul was educated in Jerusalem at the school of Gamaliel, a distinguished teacher of Jewish law.
In temperament, we know from the gospels that Simon always wanted to demonstrate his zeal for the love of Christ more than the other apostles. He promised Jesus that he would follow Him even to death, he cut off the ear of the high priest’s slave, and he cast himself into the Sea of Tiberias in order to meet Jesus after He had risen from the dead. Saul was also zealous – but for the Pharisaic law, which he studied and upheld to the extent that he persecuted the Greek-speaking ‘Hellenist’ Christians who rejected the cult of the Temple which was at the heart of Saul’s Jewish practice.
Later on, as leaders, in their opinions on faith, the gospel and the church, Peter was rooted in the church in Jerusalem and the belief that Christianity fell within the Jewish domain, whilst Paul saw his mission as being to evangelise the Gentiles, using his education in philosophy and his linguistic knowledge for dialogue, encounter, and communication with them.
Their clash over this issue resulted in the elders of the Jerusalem church calling Paul and Barnabas back from Antioch to a council to discuss whether converted Gentiles should be included in the Church. It was a difficult debate – you can read about it in Acts Chapter 15.
The issue was resolved, but tradition has continued to portray Peter and Paul on different sides of the church: and so it is said that the original ‘embracing’ icon was inspired by a series of 15th century church councils, at Florence and Ferrara, which aimed to unite the eastern and western churches. The icon was painted as a symbol of ecumenical peace. The embrace of Peter and Paul – hands on shoulders, arms across their bodies – shows them united despite their differences.
Sadly those ecumenical Councils failed to reconcile the many branches of the church; and ecumenism is still a necessity today as Christians differ on many things. But the iconographers are inspired by hope: in the deeper unity we have in the Holy Spirit, in the common mission we share.
Now this weekend in cathedrals across the country – and across the world – priests and deacons are being ordained. These are wonderful occasions of new beginnings for the individuals and their church communities; and it’s certain that many men, dressed in cassocks for the first time ever, will be hugged, possibly for the first time ever, by their fathers, sons, and lifelong friends.
I should say at this point that there are, of course, also many women involved in these occasions, indeed, in our diocese, nine women were ordained deacon at Bradford Cathedral yesterday, and four men. And that helps us to shift the focus of this sermon from being about men overcoming their natural emotional reticence, to being about church leaders overcoming their differences in background and temperament, and opinions on matters of Church and faith.
25 years ago this week I was ordained deacon, alongside sixteen others in Liverpool Cathedral, kneeling together at the altar rail for about forty minutes, whilst the ceremony proceeded. It hurt our knees then; I think it’d be agonising if I had to do it again now. In the time we spent preparing for that moment, we’d grown to know each other well with all our many differences: of character, of background, of tradition; becoming friends even whilst often failing to see eye to eye on matters of church and faith. In those solemn moments in that vast cathedral, our differences faded away as we each silently prayed along with the bishop as, one by one, he stood above us and said, “Send down the Holy Spirit upon your servant … for the office and work of a priest in your Church”. We’ve gone our many ways since, but I’m still praying for those people now, all our differences eclipsed by a unity of love and respect. [4]
Both Peter and Paul would have known, and been inspired by, God’s words through the prophet Isaiah when he wrote, “Remember not the former things, nor consider the things of old. Behold, I am doing a new thing; now it springs forth, do you not perceive it?” [5]
The mission of Peter and Paul continues; it is the mission of the newly-ordained, and the mission of all of us, to bring into being in our communities those new things which God is inviting us to see.
Let us use this occasion of The Festival of Saint Peter and Saint Paul in the way it was intended: to pray for those who are called to lead the Church in the unity of the Holy Spirit, putting aside all differences, and standing firm on the one foundation, Jesus Christ our Lord; and to pray that in a world exhausted of hope, the Holy Spirit may help us all perceive the new thing which God is doing, to embrace that joyful mission in which he invites us all to share.
Notes
[1] Channel 5, Reuben Owen: Life in the Dales, season 2, episode 6.
[2] Jim Nelson, The Embrace of Peter and Paul. JustAnotherJim, 24 August 2017; Wikipedia: Angelos Akotantos; Tamara Rigishvili, The Embrace of the Apostles Peter and Paul.
[3] Metropolitan Paul Yazigi, Something We Should Know about Apostles Peter and Paul. The Catalog of Good Deeds, 12 July 2019; Jim Nelson, The Embrace of Peter and Paul. JustAnotherJim, 24 August 2017; John Bowker, The Complete Bible Handbook. ‘The Jerusalem Council’, pp.394-395.
[4] John Davies, On Ordination, June 2001.
[5] Isaiah 43.18-19.
