This people’s history – beauty bubbling up from beneath

Exodus 1.8-2.10, Luke 2.33-35

Mothering Sunday, 30 March 2025, Clapham

She named him Moses, ‘because,’ she said, ‘I drew him out of the water.’

It is good to be revisiting the story of Exodus today. For Exodus is vibrant with meanings and metaphors for our times. It is written as a history, but no ordinary history.

Most histories are written about, and for, the ‘victors’. But the beginning of the book of Exodus is more like a hidden history, a people’s history, a secret story told out of a situation of oppression; to encourage the oppressed people that beneath the apparent power of the king who is enslaving them, a greater power is at work – the greater, though subtler and gentler, power of a God who will one day set them free. God demonstrates this power not through military might or political procedure, but through the furtive activities of sympathetic midwives and loving family members, and through a young woman’s adoption of a child she finds concealed in the reeds of a riverbank. Pharaoh’s daughter named the child Moses, ‘because,’ she said, ‘I drew him out of the water.’

This people’s history smiles at the temporary triumphs of temporal power. It is a joyful tale of beauty bubbling up from beneath. Here is the Egyptian king, worried about the growing numbers and influence of the alien Israelites in his land, putting slave masters over them to oppress them with forced labour, and plotting genocide, ordering the Hebrew midwives, Shiphrah and Puah, to kill all newborn Hebrew baby boys.

But here are two midwives who disobey Pharaoh’s instructions, two bold women who would rather save a child’s life than obey the king’s vile bidding, two midwives who draw from the water of the womb babies condemned to die. Shiphrah and Puah tell Pharaoh a lie – ‘Hebrew women give birth before we can get to them’ – as a clever excuse to ensure that the innocents live. 

Here also are Moses’ mother and sister, also avoiding Pharaoh’s deadly intentions by hiding their beloved newborn first at home for three months, and then, when that became impossible, getting a papyrus basket for him, plastering it with bitumen and pitch, putting the child in it and hiding it among the reeds on the bank of the river.

And then there is Pharaoh’s daughter, behaving notably unlike every other storybook princess – for their usual role is to passively accept rescue or marriage at the hands of a man. This young woman radically refuses to indulge her father’s abominable strategies, by saving a child by drawing him out of the water and taking him into her home. 

Through the agency of his daughter, her attendants, and these Hebrew women united in their care for the child in the bulrushes, Pharaoh unwittingly lets in to his household, Moses. This little one who God had chosen to liberate Israel, entered the palace of Pharaoh by a back door, into the nursery of Pharaoh’s daughter. The scene is set for God’s long, slow, undermining of Pharaoh’s power and the ultimately triumphant release of the Israelites, in which the role played by the hidden river child Moses is key. 

The name Moses, in Hebrew, means ‘One who draws out’. The one who was drawn out of reeds beside the River Nile by Pharaoh’s daughter so as to become established in the land of Egypt, then drew out the Israelites from their captivity, through the parting waters of the Red Sea. The child Moses, lifted out of the waters of oppression, became the adult Moses leading his people through the waters of freedom: another act in the unfolding hidden history of God’s liberating kingdom.

I’ve often said it, and I’ll never tire of repeating it, that God chooses as his birthing partners in the making of remarkable things, people whose histories are otherwise overlooked. Our remarkable  scriptures privilege and celebrate the outsiders: like the subversive midwives, the defiant mother and sister, the sympathetic princess, united by their surreptitious risk-taking actions to save a baby.

We know that the pharaohs and presidents, the CEOs and chancellors, will go on doing what they have always done, drawing ever-more power and wealth to themselves and their caste at a cost to the people and the planet. But scripture opens our hearts to the stories of those who are drawn from the waters, those at the edges facing abandonment or drowning, those at the brink of disaster. Through learning to listen to their stories we get to know the voice of God, and understand his worldview, for he so often speaks through and for such people. In scripture, and in life today. This people’s history is a story of beauty bubbling up from beneath.

One such story is that of Yifat Susskind, who works with a group called Midwives for Peace, supporting women in places of conflict and helping their voices to be heard in the halls of power – from village councils to the UN Security Council. She gives a talk called “Think Like a Mother”: “When you think like a mother,” she says, “you prioritise the needs of the many, not the whims of the few.” [2]

Scripture encourages us to see life through the lives of the world’s unsung people. Read the newspapers by all means, watch the news, listen to the radio discussions, read the history books, but understand that they’ll always tend to tell you the story the way the Pharaoh wants it told. Run what you hear and see through this test: What are the tales in scripture which relate to the events of our day? And who are the people whose seldom-heard stories we should seek out, because these are the stories that will reveal to us God’s truth?

We can also learn to read ourselves in this way. When we stop to consider our own modest lives and what they mean in the great scheme of things: 

  • let us acknowledge how God has written us into his story; 
  • let us give thanks that God saves us just like he did Moses the baby in the reeds, how he loves us just like he did Moses, and how, just like Moses, he has given us gifts to use in his service;
  • and let us be thankful for those people who once nurtured us, and those who still do, who, through their acts of love towards us, have drawn us out into lives of faith and freedom. 

 

Notes

[1] A rewrite of Drawn out of the water, preached at Bratton Clovelly, 2011.

[2] Yifat Susskind, In uncertain times, think like a mother. MADRE, 16 January 2025. 

“Oops, I did it again”: if you think you are standing, watch out that you do not fall

1 Corinthians 10.1–13, Luke 13.1–9

The Third Sunday of Lent, 23 March 2025, Austwick, Clapham

“So if you think you are standing, watch out that you do not fall”

Considered one of the most memorable moments in all of British television, and frequently top of the polls for the funniest sitcom moment ever, is the scene from Only Fools and Horses where David Jason’s Del Boy falls through an open bar counter.

You know the scene: Del Boy and Trigger are leaning against the bar eyeing up the ladies, ready to impress, when, not noticing that the barman has opened the counter behind him, Del Boy tells Trigger to “play it nice and cool son, nice and cool,” leans back, glass in hand, and falls straight to the floor. 

“So if you think you are standing, watch out that you do not fall”

There are other great comedy moments to which those words of St Paul to the Corinthians very readily apply. Like that moment in Dad’s Army when Private Pike is confronted by a German officer demanding to know his name, and Arthur Lowe’s Captain Mainwaring fills the silence, yelling out “Don’t tell him, Pike!”

“So if you think you are standing, watch out that you do not fall”

And there’s the scene in the Vicar of Dibley when in a dream-like state the Reverend Geraldine Granger is walking through a country lane with a handsome stranger, splashing through puddles, when she jumps into a deep puddle, ending up submerged chest high in muddy water. I only recently discovered that Dawn French badly twisted her knee doing that stunt, needing a steroid injection, and eventually knee replacement surgery.

“So if you think you are standing, watch out that you do not fall”

There’s a word – hubris – which means excessive pride or self-confidence. It can lead to comedy, as in those sketches; or it can equally be damaging to individuals, or society. The dictionary definition of hubris offers this example: ‘the self-assured hubris among economists was shaken in the late 1980s’. In other words they were so confident about their financial grand designs that they just did not see Black Monday coming, nor the recession which followed.

Paul wanted to warn the Corinthian believers against hubris. He gave them a history lesson to remind them how the people of Israel – with whom they now belonged – had time and again got themselves so comfortable with their elevated status as God’s chosen people, that some of them began to turn their back on their loving heavenly Father and to go their own way, becoming ‘idolaters’, Paul writes, embracing all kinds of immorality, which led to their downfall. 

“So if you think you are standing, watch out that you do not fall”, he wrote, urging them to learn from history to keep an eye on themselves, lest they too began to let themselves be calamitously led by excessive pride or self-confidence, rather than the virtues which Jesus taught them. 

Why do we humans fail to learn from our past mistakes? 

Why do we find ourselves nursing hangovers, and saying ‘never again’ just weeks after the last time we nursed a hangover, and said ‘never again’?

In our relationships why do we keep having the same disagreements over the same behaviours, finding ourselves saying, “I’ll change, I promise”, on repeat?

“Oops, I did it again,” sings Britney Spears, who just can’t help herself, and seems to be enjoying herself just that bit too much to really want to help herself to change.

We could each reel off a list of big mistakes that societies keep on repeating; and for Christians who, by faith, are now so closely connected with the people of Israel, one question troubles us more than any other today: how can a people who so recently suffered a terrible holocaust, now themselves inflict the same such deliberate mass slaughter on their Palestinian neighbours? 

In our synagogues, mosques, and churches, this current genocide in the Holy Land hangs over our worship like a dark cloud, and our judgement on it should be unclouded: we are witnesses to heinous crimes against humanity which we should do all we can to call-out and resist. [3]

Scripture shows us that in this world of conflict, outer and inner conflict, there are two ways we can go. We can repeat or we can repent. 

Firstly, Paul teaches that in history such terrible acts do not go unpunished: he says that the perpetrators, those who think they are standing, are ‘destroyed by the destroyer’: caught up in a cycle of violence, evil repays evil between empires greedy for land and power. It’s the same cycle which repeats between neighbours locked into dispute, or ceaselessly squabbling siblings.

It all seems hopelessly endless, like our world is on repeat, but Paul teaches that God provides a way for us to break this cycle: “he will not let you be tested beyond your strength,” Paul writes, “but with the testing he will also provide the way out so that you may be able to endure it.” 

Notice how there is a testing, and a way out, in Jesus’ story about the merciful gardener begging the vineyard owner to give the fruitless fig tree one more year to be tended, just one more chance to bear fruit.

This brings us to the second point. Scripture has a special word to describe the way we can break the cycle of hubris. The word is repentance. In today’s gospel passage Jesus twice says “unless you repent, you will all perish” just as other hubristic offenders perished before. 

What tone of voice does Jesus use here? How does he phrase that sentence? Let’s imagine that he’s speaking less like the merciless vineyard owner announcing his judgement before reigning down instant destruction, and more like the merciful gardener giving hope that if we turn around and allow him to tend to our spiritual well-being, then there’s every chance that, even now, we will bear fruit.

Repentance is a substantial thing. It sounds far less like “Oops, I did it again” and far more like “Amazing grace, how sweet the sound / That saved a wretch like me”. 

Repentance is what we do when we realise we think we are standing, and start watching out that we do not fall. 

Repentance is what happens when, having kept an eye on ourselves, resisting excessive pride or self-confidence, we allow God’s Spirit to lead us into the virtuous, fulfilled, life which we know can be ours in Christ.

 

Notes

[1] YouTube: Del Boy Falls Through the Bar; Don’t Tell Him, Pike!; Vicar of Dibley – Puddle.

[2] YouTube: Britney Spears, Oops!… I Did it Again.

[3] Statement on Israel’s latest assault on Gaza. Campaign Against the Arms Trade, 18 March 2025. Katie Fallon, Advocacy Manager at CAAT said: “The genocidal attack that Israel has unleashed on the people of Gaza is designed to inflict maximum suffering and terror on Palestinians. Israel has been violating the ceasefire agreement for weeks, increasing attacks and blocking all aid for over two weeks including food and fuel. Our government continues to support Israel politically and militarily through arms exports, including for F-35 jets which are used to drop 2,000 lbs bombs on Palestinians. We demand a full two way arms embargo with Israel. We demand an end to the UK government’s complicity in and military support for genocide, occupation and apartheid.”

before reigning down instant destruction, and more like the merciful gardener giving hope that if we turn around and allow him to tend to our spiritual well-being, then there’s every chance that, even now, we will bear fruit.

Repentance is a substantial thing. It sounds far less like “Oops, I did it again” and far more like “Amazing grace, how sweet the sound / That saved a wretch like me”. 

Repentance is what we do when we realise we think we are standing, and start watching out that we do not fall. 

Repentance is what happens when we keep an eye on ourselves, and, resisting excessive pride or self-confidence, allow God’s Spirit to lead us away, towards the virtuous, fulfilled, life which we know can be ours in Christ.

 

Notes

[1] YouTube: Del Boy Falls Through the Bar; Don’t Tell Him, Pike!; Vicar of Dibley – Puddle.

[2] YouTube: Britney Spears, Oops!… I Did it Again.

[3] Statement on Israel’s latest assault on Gaza. Campaign Against the Arms Trade, 18 March 2025. Katie Fallon, Advocacy Manager at CAAT said: “The genocidal attack that Israel has unleashed on the people of Gaza is designed to inflict maximum suffering and terror on Palestinians. Israel has been violating the ceasefire agreement for weeks, increasing attacks and blocking all aid for over two weeks including food and fuel. Our government continues to support Israel politically and militarily through arms exports, including for F-35 jets which are used to drop 2,000 lbs bombs on Palestinians. We demand a full two way arms embargo with Israel. We demand an end to the UK government’s complicity in and military support for genocide, occupation and apartheid.”

Our citizenship is in heaven

Philippians 3.17 – 4.1, Luke 13.31-35

The Second Sunday of Lent, 16 March 2025, Austwick

 

I used to live just around the corner from a place which has the most-often-stolen street sign in the UK, if not in the world: can you guess what street it is?

It’s Penny Lane, made famous of course by The Beatles. What is remarkable about Paul McCartney’s song is that it is not a celebration of a world heritage site, but a description of a very ordinary street, and the people who spend their days ‘there beneath the blue suburban skies’.

Penny Lane has changed a bit since the Beatles released the song in 1967, though not that much. There’s still a ‘barber showing photographs / of every head he’s had the pleasure to know’. What’s different now is that the barber’s shop sign is written in the same typeface as The Beatles used on their records, and displays the playful strap-line ‘Above us only hair’. 

Take a moment to picture a place which is special to you. It could be very ordinary and close to home, a place which may be unremarkable to the outsider, but is special to you because of the memories it holds, the associations it has for you, or simply because it’s what you regard as home. 

Or you might picture somewhere far away from here, a favourite holiday destination, maybe, or the place you spent your childhood. 

We all have places which are special to us – it’s interesting to consider why we feel that way about them. The theologian Walter Brueggemann says that it’s not so much about the place itself, but what’s happened to us there:

Place is space which has historical meaning, where some things have happened which are now remembered and which provide continuity and identity across generations. Place is space in which important words have been spoken which have established identity, defined vocation and envisioned destiny. [1]

Thus my grandmother’s kitchen where you always felt held and nurtured by family; the church where you made your marriage vows; the burial ground you visit: I’d imagine that these unremarkable looking places hold as much value – no, likely far more value – to you as the exotic cities you stopped at during that one-time sunshine cruise. 

In our mental-health-conscious society people talk a lot about going to their ‘happy place’, which can be a physical space or could just be a place within their heart and mind which lifts their spirit. The term ‘happy place’ was popularised by the BBC radio broadcaster Jordan North when in the jungle on I’m A Celebrity, he overcame his fear of snakes by chanting about his ‘happy place’ – Burnley FC’s Turf Moor stadium. Not the obvious choice for most of us, but right for him. 

‘Penny Lane’ is a good example of how music often helps us recall or celebrate our special places. There are countless other songs which do it – on the B-side of the Penny Lane 45 was Strawberry Fields Forever, John Lennon singing about the place where he played as a child with his friends. There’s plenty of songs which might come to mind to those who love these Yorkshire Dales: from ‘Take Me Home, Country Roads’ to ‘On Ilkley Moor Baht ‘at’; from ‘The Green, Green Grass of Home’ to ‘Jerusalem’…

The hymn ‘Jerusalem’ reminds us that sometimes we use places to describe our values or our visions, our hopes and our intentions. William Blake lived virtually his entire life within a small area of London, but his words, popularised in Charles Hubert Parry’s hymn, are universal – they envision God living among the English in the shape of the holiest of world cities, Jerusalem, being ‘builded here / among those dark Satanic Mills’. 

Jerusalem must be high up, if not top, of the list all the places in the world which people regard as special. It has holy significance to the world’s 16 million Jews, two-and-a-half billion Christians, and 1.9 billion Muslims. It’s a place visited by the devout seeking special blessing for their faith; and to the many more who never get to go there the very name Jerusalem symbolises something profound about the dwelling of  God among people.

When Jerusalem inspires awe, wonder and praise, it represents the best of places; when it becomes a battlefield, as it so often does, it looks like the worst.

Jesus revered the city, and loved its people as a hen loves her brood, but he also knew that ‘Jerusalem kills the prophets and stones those who are sent to it’, and that it would be the place where he would meet his end.

Jesus’ crucifixion at the hands of Jerusalem’s masters represents the awful things that happen when our sense of place gets bound up with what we might call a ‘negative nationalism’, an exclusiveness among a place’s insiders whereby they cast out or punish the outsider.

Jesus’ suffering represents the suffering of anyone who has ever been rejected from a place because they’re deemed by the occupants to not belong there; to not fit in. 

This is why Paul is keen to remind the believers that “our citizenship is in heaven” – we have our time of belonging on earth, and it is a time we’re given to enjoy, but we must always remember where our true and ultimate home is. 

When we do this, it frees us to thank God for the places which are special to us here, in unselfish appreciation of them; and this draws us closer in love and joy to Him who gives them to us.

 

Notes 

[1] Walter Brueggemann: The Land – Place as Gift, Promise, and Challenge in Biblical Faith.

Blessed are the peacemakers: sat at the kerbside empathising

A refection given at Peace is a Doing Word – living peacefully in a world of conflict, Bowland and Ewecross Deanery Lent Series, Settle Parish Church Tuesday 11 March 2025

(CLICK for Peace is a Doing Word website)

“Blessed are the peacemakers, because they will be called children of God” (Matthew 5.9)

Back in the day, at the youth club, trouble was brewing between two tough guys who had taken a dislike to each other. Words were exchanged, there was pushing and shoving between them and other members of their respective gangs. My friend Pip, the youth worker, knew that these young men were tooled up with knives, and that violence could erupt at any moment. From a safe distance I watched Pip persuade one of the gang leaders to step outside with him in a bid to try to cool the situation. Pip later told me of how scared he was for his own safety as the gang followed them into the street. He was well-schooled in the use of non-verbal communication, body language, and the next thing I saw him do has stuck with me always. With the gang leader yelling in his face, and the others surrounding him, Pip broke the tension by sitting down at the kerbside, at the feet of the gang… from where he continued to talk to the young men, asking them what was troubling them that night.

Long story short, now picture Pip and the gang leader a little later, sitting alongside each other in the gutter, the young man spilling out his life story – not a pretty one – and Pip all ears, empathising; the tension diffused, the gangs back together inside, playing pool. [1]

Jesus said, “Blessed are the peacemakers, because they will be called children of God”, and because I knew that Jesus was Pip’s inspiration, Jesus became my inspiration too. I learned that peacemaking was at the heart of Jesus’ teaching, and practice. Stories like the one where Jesus invites himself to the house of the money-grubbing taxman Zacchaeus, and, transformed by this surprise intervention, Zacchaeus joyfully gives half of his possessions to the poor, and pays people back four times the amount he had cheated from them. Stories like those where Jesus gets himself invited to sit at the meal tables of the community’s great and good, and brings along with him the community’s outcasts and stragglers, creating a unique space for them all to break bread together. 

From the Sermon on the Mount, from which this quote is taken, I learn that Jesus places peacemakers not in exalted company, but among the poor, those who mourn, and the meek: in other words among society’s vulnerable, troubled and lost souls, the victimised and the abused. In this teaching, Peacemakers know their place – and that is: sat at the kerbside empathising with those whose life stories are not pretty.

Empathising – then acting on what they hear and see. For Jesus continues by saying that ‘Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness’. Blessed are those who see that peacemaking is an activity for those who are learning to see the world through the eyes of those on the receiving end of rapacious wealth and power, and who will do what they can to right the wrongs which trouble the delicate ecology of the earth, its creatures and its peoples. 

Jesus taught that peacemakers can expect trouble: they’ll be lied about, insulted, and persecuted. And his life shows that often the trouble comes from those you’d expect to be your allies. How often he was in conflict with the religious authorities, for instance, over the ways they’d turned the law into a burden on the poor; how he literally upset the unholy traders in The Temple: was this why he said that he’d come to bring ‘not peace, but a sword’? He was teaching that peacemaking is an unsettling business.

His methods clearly unsettled his own supporters, who often failed to ‘get’ what he was doing, giving his time to women of low repute and soldiers of the hated occupying Roman army. And it is remarkable to note how often it is a military man who understands who Jesus is and affirms him in his mission: the centurion whose servant Jesus heals then says ‘I have not found anyone in Israel with such great faith’; the soldier at the foot of the cross who is the first to realise that the crucifixion is a liberating act of God. 

From this I have learned to see how peacemakers come in all forms and types; over the years I’ve found some of the richest conversations about peacemaking in dialogues between military strategists and peace movement activists. [2]

The beatitudes of Jesus make no sense at all to those who despair of the injustices of the world. Where is the blessing for the poor and meek? When will it ever come? How could it ever happen?

But what the beatitudes do – and what Jesus did in his life, death and resurrection, ‘is to make hope possible, rather than despair convincing’. [3]

However hopeless the situation may look on the surface of things, peacemakers of all faiths and none are motivated by a sure and certain hope: that though change may be a long time coming, in the words of Sam Cooke, a change is going to come.

 

PLAY Sam Cooke, A Change Is Gonna Come

 

Silence 

 

Closing Prayer

Now when Jesus saw the crowds, he went up on a mountainside and sat down. His disciples came to him, and he began to teach them. He said:

“Blessed are the poor in spirit, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.

Blessed are those who mourn, for they will be comforted.

Blessed are the meek, for they will inherit the earth.

Blessed are those who hunger and thirst for righteousness, for they will be filled.

Blessed are the merciful, for they will be shown mercy.

Blessed are the pure in heart, for they will see God.

Blessed are the peacemakers, for they will be called children of God.

Blessed are those who are persecuted because of righteousness, for theirs is the kingdom of heaven.

Blessed are you when people insult you, persecute you and falsely say all kinds of evil against you because of me. Rejoice and be glad, because great is your reward in heaven, for in the same way they persecuted the prophets who were before you.

You are the salt of the earth.” [4]

Amen

 

Notes

[1] Based on many conversations with the late Pip Wilson, and content in his memoir Gutter Feelings.

[2] In particular Alastair McIntosh who, in 2018 after 20 years of speaking annually on the Advanced Command & Staff Course at the Joint Services Command & Staff College, was presented with a silver paper knife with the engraved words, “For broadening our horizons.” He makes this contribution to a British military standard textbook, Ethics, Law and Military Operations.

[3] Based on a quote widely attributed to Raymond Williams, “To be truly radical is to make hope possible rather than despair convincing”.

[4] Matthew 5.1-13.